Reviewing the Weekend's NISA Independent Cup Action

GEORGIA REVOLUTION FC 2   SODA CITY FC 2

Soda City’s drive to the championship was a clear path: a win against Georgia Revolution and they would be in the final. With the hardest game out of the way, Georgia Revolution looked to take some points in this game and had a different look to its starting lineup. William and John Eskay both got the start on the offensive side, while wonderstriker Todd Fidler was not in the starting lineup for the Revs (much to the disappointment of Dan Creel and yours truly).  

The first fifteen minutes was an even trading of possession, until Soda City’s captain Hunter Haynes went down with an injury and had to be replaced. The Revs controlled possession much of the half after that point, while Soda City was content to absorb the pressure. Youngster Noel Elder would push up from his left back position for the Revs and into the offensive side more – something that would play a factor in the final result (a little foreshadowing here). 

The half ended without a goal being scored, but you just had the feeling that goals were coming. And did they ever.

It was Soda City who dictated the pace early in the second half, pushing the ball forward with the most offensive urgency seen by them so far in the tournament. And the efforts would be rewarded in the 55th minute when Graham Jermstad stole a chested back pass that went astray and was brought down in the box by the Revs’ Jake Mathis for a clear penalty. Jermstad would convert from the spot, and Soda City had a lead.

But the Revs were not done. At the 68th minute, young Elder would take a pass at the left corner of the 18 and push two Soda City players to go after him, taking him down and giving the Revs their own chance from the penalty spot. Forward Ryan King went far right and calmly tied the game up at 1-1.

Image courtesy of Chattanooga FC Social Media.

In the 82bd minute, the sound was lost during the live stream – right before one amazing goals was scored. From about 25 yards out, Soda City took a free kick and whipped it in to the 18 to Graham Jermstad, who took the ball off one bounce off his chest, then with his back to goal booted the ball with his left foot over his left shoulder and just inside the upper right corner of the net. Wow! Surely this would be the goal that would send Soda City to the championship!

But then – oh no…poor Henry Kohel.

The Soda City defender, running back towards his goal on a headed ball from the Revs, mis-kicked and sent the ball even closer to goal. The Revs’ Ryan King caught up with it, and lofted a shot over a helpless Jack Pondy right at the 86th minute. A gut punch of a goal. The score was level once again.

The last six minutes (and extra time) were helter skelter, with minds and hearts willing to make one more push but tired legs giving out. The final whistle sounded, and Georgia Revolution were alive for another week. For Soda City, so close to punching their ticket to the championship, they now have to come home to face Chattanooga FC knowing that they may still need a result.         

CHATTANOOGA FC 3   SAVANNAH CLOVERS 0

The favored CFC looked the part in taking care of Georgia Revolution last week. Would it be more of the same again the Clovers? In a word, yes. 

Chattanooga would follow the script from last week and score early. In the 11th minute, Ryan Marcano, who was a substitute in last week’s game, took a pass in stride to the right of goal, drove hard towards the keeper, then zipped in pass in front to goal to a charging Brain Bement who drilled it first time past the keeper. 

Just a mere five minutes later, Ian McGrath would find himself at the top of the 18 after some nice one-touch passing and sent a low, driving ball past a ‘where did that come from’-looking J.W. May for the second goal. It was not a good look for May and the Clovers team as a whole, as they seemed frozen and caught off guard by the sequence. Sixteen minutes in, and CFC was in change with a 2-0 lead.

Would Savannah respond? Well, the response was to not press and push the offense. Chattanooga had no trouble moving the ball up the field, and the Clovers kept Timo Mesa alone up front and struggled to get any kind of service. The half ended 2-0, and without a sense of urgency from Savannah.  

At the 52nd minute a terrible back pass by Savannah from midfield was intercepted by Kalib Jackson, who drove past the one defender in his path and sent a shot through the legs of the ‘keeper. It was 3-0, and CFC were well on their way to clinching a spot in the region’s championship game.

It would not be until the 75th minute did Savannah bring on another offensive player and attempted to push forward. But the result seemed too little, too late. Things did get a little testy in the final minutes of the game with multiple incidents that would eventually bring out the red card for each team from pushing and shoving. Maybe Savannah could have brought that fire earlier in the game.

And so Chattanooga, to the surprise of no one, has made it to the championship game regardless of its final game against Soda City his coming weekend. For Savannah, now eliminated, they have one last opportunity to showcase its club and a chance to play spoiler against the Georgia Revolution.    

Previewing This Weekend's Independent Cup Matches

Another group joins the fray. The Southeast Region has to share the spotlight this weekend as the Central Plans Region begins play in the NISA Independent Cup.  

Southeast Region

Soda City FC v Georgia Revolution FC - July 18th @ 5PM ET (Finley Stadium, Chattanooga TN)

The first of two games being played at Finley Stadium in Chattanooga is a UPSL/NPSL battle between Soda City (1-0-0) and Georgia Revolution (0-1-0). A combination of solid goaltending and an opportunistic offense was the formula in Soda City’s win over Savannah Clovers. While there’s no doubt about Jack Pondy in goal, Soda City could use more offensive oomph from Graham Jermstad and company up front.

The Revs had their moments against Chattanooga FC but was ultimately outclassed in the 3-1 loss. Against Soda City, a hope for more offense coming from Todd Fidler, Braham Gamarra and the Brothers Eskay. It will be interesting to see if the Revs use the press more often in this game to force turnovers without having to be as concerned with their opponent’s fire power on the counter. A loss would essentially eliminate the Revs, so expect them to push the action in an attempt to dictate the terms. Will Pondy be a source of frustration?     

Savannah Clovers FC v Chattanooga FC - July 18th @ 8PM ET (Finley Stadium, Chattanooga TN)

A first game loss and staring elimination in face against the best team in the group. – not the way the Savannah Clovers (0-1-0) had hoped things would go. But here they are, and a big effort is what is going to be needed. We saw some flashes of elusiveness with Timo Mesa, and he is going to have to bring his A+++ game and give CFC’s back line fits. Georgia Revolution showed that you can press Chattanooga effectively at times. Will the Clovers be confident to send numbers forward? 

For CFC, we got a taste of what Zeca, Ian McGrath and Brian Bement can do together in the first game. How will they look after another week of training? The arrow is pointing up. One thing to look for is whether newbie goalie Alec Redington can deliver another solid performance. Could a soft goal throw off his game? Will Savannah be able to even get a chance to score a soft goal? 

Central Plains Region

Editors Note: The league notified us that this match has been moved to next weekend, due to local protocols.

Louisiana Krewe FC v Gaffa FC (St. Julien Park, Broussard LA)

The first of a home-and-still home between Louisiana Krewe and Gaffa FC being played in Louisiana. Easy on the traveling for the Krewe, no doubt. Although both clubs are from the Gulf Coast Premier League, they did not face each other last season due to playing in different conferences.  

Gaffa FC from Jackson, Mississippi, have not played a competitive match since last July due to the cancellation of the 2020 GCPL season. Winners of the GCPL in their first season (2017), Gaffa just missed out on the GCPL playoffs in 2019. This is a club that has a mix of veteran players from around the world who are coaches themselves as well as young players from the local area. The team is led by their Manchester-born center back Tom Cosgrave who will be on the roster for this tournament. 

Based in Lafayette, Louisiana, Louisiana Krewe have only played one season in the GCPL but enjoyed moderate success and made some noise by qualifying for the 2020 Open Cup. And yes, the club has had a certain soccer website on the front of its kits. Like Gaffa FC, Krewe have constructed a roster that has many international players but also give an opportunity for local players. Will Krewe continue its successful run of play?     

- John Howard-Fusco

Ryan's Weekend Wrap Up 7/10-7/12

THE ROJA LEAGUE

Diablos Estudiantes 2 - 0 NTX Rayados

I’ve been a bit slow to the lesson, but consider me now properly instructed on not ever doubting the abilities of Denton’s junior side. The Estudiantes have grown, and risen to the occasion, of each match, and every opponent, presented to them. This was never more evident as it was in their body of work vs NTX Rayados on Saturday night, where the Estudiantes posted an early two- goal lead in the first half, then showed a discipline they’d be lacking in earlier outings by shutting down the veteran Rayados and preventing any opportunity or hope for the visitors that they might make a comeback or share a point.

Estudiantes have held onto their league lead atop the standings, and will play the rest of the season out with a target on their back. Perhaps it may be too daunting a task to maintain their place at the top, but don’t choose against the youngsters yet.

Denton Diablos 4 -1 Fort Worth Vaqueros

Be honest, If you were tuned into this match, and not from Fort Worth, you were pulling for the Diablos. We all love an underdog story, and while The Chisolm Trail Clasico may only be in its second year, it’s already brought much heartache to the Denton side still seeking an inaugural victory against the Vaqueros after two 2019 NPSL regular season matches, one playoff match, and two eNPSL matches.

From the opening kickoff, the Diablos were committed to setting the pace and closing that chapter of heartbreak, and they’d score first at the 21st minute with an expertly turned shot beyond the diving effort of the Fort Worth goalkeeper and buried in the bottom left corner of the net. Seemingly aware of past histories versus the Vaqueros, in which Denton had scored the opening match in all past meetings, the Diablos continued to maintain a predominantly offensive shape and struck for a second goal 4 minutes later. Denton fans may have seen ghosts of Chisholm Trails past when the Vaqueros found a score just before halftime to shave the Diablo lead to just a goal, but a converted penalty in the 61’ and a final score in the 87’ gave Denton an emphatic first win against Fort Worth. The Diablos will also travel down to Cowtown for the second leg of the clasico with a commanding lead.

Inocentes FC 3- 3 Irving FC

Inocentes was a worthy favorite, along the likes of NTX Rayados, to win the inaugural Roja League, at least in my mind. They're a club rich in history, culture, community and developing highly competitive sides, most recently reaching the UPSL championship game in the Fall 2018 season, where they would only fall to the now-professional side California Strikers in penalties.All that history and success clearly hasn’t been lost on their opponents so far in the Roja League season, as Inocentes is absorbing everyone’s evident best shot. Denton’s first team kept clawing back in a season opening, thrilling, 4-4 draw. Fort Worth, while woeful in other contests, brought their A effort to the inaugural Cowtown Clasico in a 1-1 game. And now Irving FC, desperate to improve their position in the standings after an admirable in a 3-2 loss to Rayados and a draw with Denton, clawed their way back from an early deficit to claim a 3-3 finale. Both sides have looked strong and been highly competitive on the pitch, but they’re each still looking for their elusive first victory of the season.

THE HEARTLAND SUPER CUP

Southwest Region

Garden City Potrillos FC 2 - 0 Atletico Liberal FC

The southwest region of the heartland Super Cup kicked off in west Kansas this past weekend, with the Potrillos, or “Colts” of Garden City claiming a 2-0 advantage over neighboring Atletico Liberal FC.

Dodge City Toros FC 0 - 1 FC Wichita U20’s

Proving that playing their under-20 youth to winning results isn’t limited to the Denton Diablos, FC Wichita’s U20’s traveled to western Kansas and battled a stout Dodge City Toros lineup to a scoreless stalemate late into the match. The Reds then found a late goal, and 3 vital points with it, to carry back to Wichita ahead of hosting the rest of their group matches this weekend.

North Region

Iowa Raptors FC 7 - 0 Raptors Reserves

Springfield FC 3 - 0 Raptors Reserves

Iowa Raptors FC 2 - 0 Omaha Kings FC

Springfield FC 1 - 1 Omaha Kings FC

USL League 2 expansion side Iowa Raptors hosted the North Region in Cedar Rapids, and easily swept aside the Reserves, before defeating the Omaha Kings FC inaugural outdoor side. Omaha, a member of the indoor PASL league, would put together a strong effort in a draw versus the UPSL’s Springfield FC. The side from Illinois would later find a win against the Raptor’s Reserves. The group enters the second weekend of play with Iowa Raptors leading with 6 pts, Springfield sitting at 3 points, Omaha with a 1 point and the Reserves at 0.

UNITED PREMIER SOCCER LEAGUE

Panther United FC 2 - 0 APTX CDF 

& 

Panther United FC 2 - 3 Houston FC 2 

It was a mixed bag of results for Panther United FC this past week. They scored a win and a clean sheet against APTC CDF on Tuesday, then fell in a surprisingly close effort to Houston FC 2 over the weekend in Central Conference - South, Division 2 action.

Houston FC 2 - 1 Athletic Houston FC

The UPSL Central Conference - South, Division One Battle for Houston, bragging rights, and the division lead was as well contested, and thrilling, a match as was hoped for. HFC and AHFC competed intensely all 90 minutes,through the hot and humid conditions, of their midday match. Houston scored two goals late in the first half, then hung on through an Athletic Houston rally for the victory.

Celta Gunners 0 - 2 The Mix SC

No two teams have met so far this season in the midst of such drastic changes in fortunes. Two matches ago, Celta Gunners were a victory away from the Southeast Conference - Central Florida West, Division One lead. In contrast, The Mix were wading through their inaugural season with great struggle, trading the basement of the standings at turns with Diaspora United CC. After The Mix spring the commanding upset of Celta though, the Gunners sit in last place and The Mix are in the mix (sorry!) for postseason play.

Leg A-Z International SA 3 - 1 Clay County SC

In the battle for second place behind Southeast Conference - Central Florida East’s leading OFC Barca, Leg A-Z InterSA may be the only club remaining with a chance of knocking off OFCB. They headed off the visitors from neighbouring Clay County by a 3-1 margin and claim one of only two undefeated records in division play. The other? Leg A-Z INterSA’s next opponent, OFC Barca.

FK Orlando 4 - 2 Orlando Rovers FC

One of the better matches I watched this week, from one of the more interesting selected angles. Much of the game was partially obscured from the camera’s perch in the far corner of the pitch by the timed lawn sprinklers, but from what I could make out, FK Orlando proved the better team on the day and quietly hangs around to make things interesting for future fixtures against OFC Barca and Leg A-Z InterSA. The Orlando Rovers, meanwhile, continue to provide competitive play on the field, just without the elusive win. That should come in a few more of their matches to come.

OFC Barca 4 - 2  Macca Ballers FC

Macca Ballers gave a competitive effort against division leaders OFC Barca, but OFCB eventually pulled away for a comfortable, two-scores, win.

Royal Palms SC 0 - 10 Sporting Orlando SC

Remember last week when I said this match could get ugly, fast? Well, this match got ugly, fast. Sporting Orlando SC carried to hangover from their loss to OFCB into this matchup, and instead took out their frustrations from the week prior on Royal Palms SC, a side now boasting an alarming -17 goal differential through just three games.

Arctic Rush 1 - 1 Fairbanks SC

& 

Fairbanks SC 1 - 4 Arctic Rush

The northernmost team in a national league, Fairbanks SC debuted against Arctic Rush in Anchorage, playing a doubleheader between the sides over the weekend. The visitors held their own in a game one, earning the draw and a point. However, Arctic came back in dominant fashion the following day to pick up a victory ahead of a rematch versus Last Frontier Conference leaders, Alaska Timbers, next week.

FC Arizona U23 0 - 4 Olympians FC

Another week, another victory, another clean sheet, another three points for Olympians FC in Southwest Conference play. It doesn’t look like they’ll find a serious competitor in the conference until post-covid pay returns and the likes of Sporting Arizona, FC Grande, and Southwest FC make their reappearance. If you aren’t yet watching Olympians FC, and have them as potential favorites for the national title, you should be.

Diaspora United 3 -3 Florida Tropics SC 2

Diaspora United continues to improve each week on the pitch, following up their draw with The Mix SC last week with a draw versus Florida Tropics SC 2 this weekend. The Tropics meanwhile, have just one point in the past two matches and appear to be fading down the stretch if they can’t turn the results around this week.

Alaska Timbers 12 - 4 MatSu United FC

The Timbers certainly arently looking ahead to the rematch versus Arctic Rush. MatSu United might be competitive against Fairbanks SC, maybe.

REMAINING UPSL ROUNDUP

Greenspoint Gunners FC 2 - 2 Barca School of Excellence, FORO SC 2 -1 Arlington FC, NTX Legends 2 - 0 Real Irving CD, APTX CDF 3 - 2  La Maquina , FC Arizona 1 - 2 East Valley FC, Almeyda FC 2 1 - 0 Houston Hotshots,

FC Sharp Keys 4 -3 FC Bago, Junior FC 0 - 3  Kernow Storm FC, Roc City Boom 0 - 0 Greater Binghampton FC, 

& Roc City Boom 1 - 1 Krajisnik FC 

FRIENDLIES & EXHIBITIONS

Philadelphia Lone Star FC 3 - 0 Allentown United FC (Friendly), Santa Fe NY 1 - 0 Connecticut Roma (Friendly)

Livonia City FC 1 - 1 Grand Rapids FC (Friendly), and Sunflower State FC 5 - 0 Arkansas Wolves FC (Friendly)

NISA Independent Cup Recap – Opening Weekend

CHATTANOOGA FC 3   GEORGIA REVOLUTION FC 1

Game night had finally arrived at Finley Stadium in 2020, albeit under most unusual of circumstances. The home side Chattanooga FC would not have the usual big crowd on hand, but being able to play a competitive match again would be enough motivation. And it would not be a NISA match but a NISA Independent Cup match against an old NPSL rival Georgia Revolution FC.

The Revs started a defensive-minded lineup with Ryan King as the lone striker. The talk of the lineup was between midfielder Braham Gamarra (the man to watch from the commentators), head coach Scott Redding calling his own number into the Starting XI, and defender Noel Elder – and at age 16 was hardly an ‘elder’ statesman on the field.  

CFC came out with a lineup that was quite different from the last time we saw the team play a competitive match. Only three of the Starting XI started against the Oakland Roots in the opening game of the curtailed NISA spring season. One of the new players was not new at all for fans of CFC: Jose “Zeca” Ferraz, who has been part of the club going back to 2013. The insertion of Zeca gave Chattanooga a more potent offensive look. 

Image courtesy of CFC social media.

And it didn’t take long for CFC to get on the scoresheet as Zeca fed a streaking Richard Dixon down the right side who sent a ball into the box that Ian McGrath got a foot to before the defender and slipped it in near post for 1-0 lead in the sixth minute. Zeca and McGrath would help create multiple chances over the next few minutes, and you started to get the feeling that this was going to be an easy night for the home side. 

But the Revs weren’t ready to go down just yet. Quickly down the field after a CFC missed chance, Georgia midfielder Todd Fidler would find himself with the ball just outside the 18 and would uncork a rocket that found the upper corner and even the score. POW! Game on! And for the next ten minutes, the Revs would find some success in picking spots to press CFC, creating some turnovers. But Chattanooga didn’t panic, with defender Alec McKinley keeping things tidy in the back.  

The game settled back down for Chattanooga, and Zeca would once again make his mark, delivering a well-weighted pass to a streaking Brian Bement to the right of goal. Bement’s long putt of a shot tucked in just inside the far post, and CFC were back in front. Bement, who had been on the quiet side of things for much of the first half before that goal would have more to say in the second half.   

And so on to that second half – or, at least those of us watching on mycujoo tried to go on to that second half. But to no avail. The streaming service froze up and could not get back to live action until almost twenty minutes had elapsed. So while those of us on muycujoo fumed, the trio of McGrath, Zeca and Bement would put the game on ice. A long ball from middle of the field from McGrath would be headed down by Zeca and onto the path of Bement, and he clinically slotted it home.

The last fifteen minutes of the match saw play open up, and while the Eskay brothers came on and injected some life into the Revolution’s offense, the team could not sustain enough pressure to really mount a stiff enough challenge.

With the win, Chattanooga put themselves in a great position to be in the championship game. Along with the trio of offensive players, honorable mentions should be made for midfielder Juan Hernandez for his work in transitioning CFC from defense to offense as well as for goalkeeper Alec Redington in his first professional start.   

For the Revolution, Todd Fidler made his presence felt with his goal and his lack of fear in taking shots from all over the place. I don’t think there’s a spot of the pitch where Fidler doesn’t think he can get it on frame.  

One more word about mycujoo: simply put, this kind of problem must stop happening, or NISA needs to pick a new platform for streaming. But while the freeze up by mycujoo was frustrating, that in no way took away from the overall production of the game. The play-by-play provided by John Freeman and Dale Schilly was solid and professional. Their commentary was an enhancement to the match. 

---

SAVANNAH CLOVERS 1   SODA CITY FC 2

OK – since I could only watch one game live, I chose to go with the CFC v Revs game. This game I decided to watch the replay. And evidently the first ten minutes there was a problem with the feed, so we pick up the action already in progress…

Soda City and Savannah Clovers are division rivals in the UPSL, so they know each other all too well. And it didn’t take long for play to get a little chippy, with Savannah getting a yellow card within the first twenty minutes of the game. It would not be the only yellow card in the first half.

It would be Soda City striking first, as a long free kick would bounce through a maze of players and find an unmarked Dominik Byars for an easy header in the 19th minute. 

But the lead would be short-lived ad the Clovers would push the action the other way. Forward Timo Mesa looked particularly dangerous, giving Soda City defenders fits. ‘Keeper Jack Pondywas called upon to make a great reaction save on a point blank shot. But on the ensuing corner kick, Pondy could only deflect the ball away, and Henry Banegas would side volley a shot past the Soda City goalkeeper.

Image courtesy of Savannah Clovers social media.

The second half would see both teams take turns in pushing the action to create chances. But the difference would come down to the play of the goalkeepers. Jack Pondy stood tall – literally – as he handled every dangerous opportunity that came his way. At the other end, J.W. May didn’t make himself big enough when Soda City’s Troy Paul (a second-half substitute) took a lovely weighted pass and found himself behind the Clovers’ defense. May came out to challenge, but Paul got there first and floated one over the prone keeper and into the goal at the 84th minute.   

Savannah was a little unfortunate to not get points out of this one. They seem like a club with a lot of good pieces that when they put it together will be formidable. For Soda City, the game spoke volumes about the needs for a good goalkeeper. I’m not sure if Jack Pondy was the best player of the field, but the was by far the most poised.  

Oh, and a word about the commentary. While not at the same level of professionalism as the Chattanooga crew, these guys were enjoying themselves and were knowledgeable about both teams. And I could swear that one of the guys (Don) was doing his best Josh Duder impersonation. Oh – and it’s OK to say “NEEsa” – you don’t have to spell it out.

- John Howard-Fusco

Forecasting the Independent Cup

Here comes the independent tournament for independent clubs and the independent people who think and act independently. NISA’s inaugural Independent Cup gets going this weekend, and we’re here to give you a preview of the games that will be taking place.

For the opening weekend, the Southeast Region has things all to their own. The two games being played on Saturday will be taking place at the same time (Methinks that maybe this could have been avoided since, y’know, your entire audience will be people streaming the games. But what do I know, and this digression is going on and on, so…).   

Soda City FC v Savannah Clovers FC - July 11th @ 8PM ET (Memorial Stadium, Savannah GA)

So why is Columbia, South Carolina “Soda City”? Locals can fact-check me, but the story seems to go that Columbia was referred to as Cola for short, and because of this it earned the city the nickname. 

While you ponder that, let us look at Cola’s own Soda City FC. Since joining the UPSL in the fall of 2018, the team has been quite impressive: 22 wins, 3 draws and 4 losses in its first three seasons, winning its conference the last two seasons. Soda City’s success on the field reached another level this past fall, when the club made it all the way to the National Semi-final against Maryland Bobcats - taking a 2-0 lead before losing 3-2. The club has stayed focused on local players, and one to watch is goalkeeper Jack Pondy (a First Team Best XI in the fall season). 

One of Soda City’s conference rivals in the UPSL is Savannah Clovers who joined the league in Spring 2018. The two sides have met in the playoffs, with Savannah having beaten Soda City 3-0 in the fall 2018 playoff encounter. Savannah has been playing some friendlies in preparation for the tournament, including a 6-2 beatdown delivered to Charleston United last weekend (Does a 6-2 beatdown completely cancel out the term ‘friendly’? Asking for a friend). Forward Timo Mesa scored five of the six goals, so it says here that he will be a man to keep an eye on for Savannah.       

Georgia Revolution FC v Chattanooga FC - July 11th @ 8PM ET (Finley Stadium, Chattanooga TN)

To the surprise of no one, Chattanooga looks to be clear favorite in this region. But as we know, nothing is won on paper (except maybe tic tac toe). CFC looked like a team that belonged in its first NISA match – a spirited 1-1 draw on the road against Oakland Roots in a game that will forever be known as The Tie That Became a T-Shirt. So how will Ian McGrath and the boys come back after the layoff? Motivated is my guess. And as an added bonus for the local fans, this game will be televised in Chattanooga. The rest of us poor slobs will have to mycujoo it.  

Oh by the way, there will be another team on the field. Georgia Revolution FC from he NPSL and the Atlanta District Amateur Soccer League (ADASL for those in the know) started up only a couple of years after Chattanooga FC and were rivals in the NPSL right up through 2019. Like the Savannah Clovers, Georgia Revolution were prepping for the tournament by having played a recent friendly. The roster for the Revs features players who play locally but have come from all over the world. The tournament could be a showcase event for some of these players, as well as with players from all the amateur clubs, to move up in their soccer journey.   

- John Howard-Fusco

Expansion Targets: Imagining the NISA Map (emphasis on IMAGINING)

Hey there – fellow Knight John back for another speculative NISA piece. Keep in mind that it’s all in good fun.  Hope you enjoy.

If you are as staunch a follower of NISA expansion as Dan and I – the Knights Who Say NISA – then you may have noticed that all of the new teams coming on board seem to be located on the eastern half of the country. What about locations west of the Mississippi? Sure, there are four clubs huddled – sorry, clustered – in California, but nothing between them and Detroit City. Well, except the big NISA logo that they insist on planting smack dab in the middle of the map of the United States on the league’s website. (Hmmm…maybe that’s the problem…)

Well, Dan and I decided that something needed to be done. We agreed to sit down and put together some ideas of markets where NISA should consider when looking to add clubs. And when Dan got up to take a potty break, I went to work. (How that chair got lodged in between the floor and the door handle I’ll never know.)

Now if we’re playing by NISA’s ‘rules’ we have to cluster clubs together, not just throw teams hither and yon. Heartily accepting the challenge, here’s where I think the league should go when going west:

Market #1: Chicago

Wait just a minute – why would you want to have new third division clubs in a market where the Chicago Fire have done such a great job in capturing the region’s soccer fans?

Yeah, exactly. 

As the Fire have smoldered away, Chicago is beyond ready for more professional clubs. Some would argue that the city could use one professional soccer club right now, but that would be too cruel. Sort of. Anyway, since NISA is now home of the New York Cosmos, I think it would be nice to bring back another soccer team name from the past. No, not the Sting. Further back. While Fall River Marksmen and Bethlehem Steel were creating history nearly a century ago, Chicago Sparta ABA was becoming a powerhouse in the Midwest with a stadium of their own. Won championships. Hosted international exhibitions. And as far as I can tell, the moniker is not currently being used. So why not draw on some real soccer history in the region and bring back Chicago Sparta?

For our instant rival to Sparta, we’re going to take a musical journey. In the late 1960s a group of seven musical lads from Chicago sought out their fame and fortune. By 1977, the band Chicago had become a hit-making machine. The album released that year would feature a map of the city on the cover. And so, with apologies to the club currently playing in Indiana, I give you the name of that album and your new club: Chicago XI. Imagine a supporters group named after guitarist Terry Kath. A horn section playing along with the chanting fans. Baby, what a big surprise that would be.  

Market #2: Denver

Oh - surely you’re not going to go up against the mighty Rapids now, too.

Oh surely we are.

If there is an MLS club that has needed a good ol’ relegatin’, it’s the Colorado Rapids. The question is: if you could drop the Rapids into the USL, would the investor-operator even notice? But I digress. Another club name that needs to be brought back is the Colorado Foxes. For you young people out there, there was a hip and happening soccer league back in the 1990s called the APSL, the American Professional Soccer League. And the Foxes were league winners for two years. A fella by the name of Marcelo Balboa played on the club. Eventually the league called itself the A-League, merged with the USISL (the USL as we know them now), and the Foxes would fade away. Bring back the Foxes, and maybe even partner up with Leicester City. Foxy!   

And for the Foxes’ clusterbuddy, let’s have a bit of fun and get the munchies along the way. I can’t think of a better club name that embraces the region (and is pun-riffic) than Four & Twenty Blackbirds. Oh c’mon, just picture a crest that has a blackbird with a doobie resting in its beak? How would you not want this? Listen, I understand that there could be issues with having a club name that, well, more than hints at drug use, but if you don’t think the day that kit is released it isn’t flying off the shelves…

Market #3: Montana

OK, now you’re just being silly.

Sure, there may be bigger markets to plant a flag. OK – there may be MANY other markets that are bigger. But sometimes you have to zig when others say zag. Maybe the lack of professional soccer clubs in this region could spark an interest. Did anyone expect New Mexico United to draw over 10,000 a game in its inaugural season last year? 

So let’s go clustering in Big Sky Country. I’m going to eschew Billings, Great Falls, Missoula and Bozeman for now. No disrespect to these fine communities, but I think I’ve got the perfect pairing. Say hello to your newest soccer rivalry: Real Butte and Helena Handbasket FC.

OK – perhaps I am being a little silly.

Welp, I think Dan is about to break through the door, so I should end it here. We’ll be watching and waiting for the next clubs to join the NISA fraternity with curiosity.

A COVID19 Report Card: Grading the Leagues' Response to the Pandemic

With the UWS finally cancelling their season, we’ve finally reached the conclusion of leagues we cover. With that in mind, I’m going to recap how and when each club decided how to handle their season in the time of pandemic and I’ll give them a rating A-F. I used to be a middle school teacher, so I should be able to handle this.

How it Happened: The spring season kicked off, sparking a ton of excitement, with newcomers Detroit City FC, Chattanooga FC, and Michigan Stars bringing a surge of talent to the league. Two weeks into the season, the pandemic was finally ramping up to the point it couldn’t be ignored. On March 12th, the league office announced it would be putting the spring season on hold for 30 days to allow the situation to unfold. After a month and a half, the league officially pulled the plug on April 27th.

The Aftermath: When the league announced the spring cancellation, they immediately announced plans for a summer challenge cup that would involve multiple amateur clubs along with NISA sides. As of now, that is still in the works. NISA also set up an eLeague and began play. The league has also made an announcement about the format and schedule of the fall season, giving fans a lot to look forward to. NISA finances are less clear than many leagues, so how they handled the obvious losses, it’s hard to tell from the outside. We do know some clubs are definitely continuing to honor player contracts and there are some that have not.

Got it almost perfect - regular communication, few leaks, future plans in place to hold fan attention. Only miss, player salaries.

How it Happened: Rumblings of the cancelled season began leaking very soon after talks began. I received multiple contacts from within the league that this was coming, but had to hold until we had concrete information. Unlike the UPSL, which has a fall season to regroup in, the NPSL, mostly due to the collegiate players, has to play in the early summer. On March 25th, Michael Lewis of Front Row Soccer put out a story claiming the league was cancelling the 2020 season. Soon after, we received confirmation from sources in the league and ran the story as well. The plan had been for the league to announce the cancellation the next day. Leaks happen.

An internal email revealed the league was relying on the decision from USASA, which recommended cancelling any group through April 30th. The league decided it was best to cancel the season.

The Aftermath: While the decision to cancel the season was probably the right one, the league was prepared an eLeague rollout soon after. That helped take a tiny bit of the heat off the league in the social media sector, but there were some issues that emerged, regardless.

In a move that at least one other league would mirror, the NPSL decided to keep the entirety of the league fee, while only supplying a partial credit for 2021. The fee of $5,500 was reduced to a $2,000 credit. I can tell you, clubs are NOT happy about this move. Maybe it’s a reality is grassroots soccer, but it felt really unfair to clubs operating on a shoestring budget.

And aside from that decision, everything the league did leaked before it was officially announced. This is good from a media perspective, but not good if you’re a league trying to crisis manage.

Not Good, Bob - kept their league fees, leaked like a sieve, pissed off their fans and clubs.

WPSL

How it Happened: On March 20th, the WPSL announced they would be postponing the start of the league by a month, moving the season kickoff from May 9th to May 29th. The press release contained a word of caution from Sean Jones, “If the situation doesn’t seem to be improving by the end of April and our top medical experts are recommending avoiding outdoor activities, then the WPSL will comply and not compete in 2020. We have informed our teams that we will provide them 30 days advanced notice if the cancelation does take place.” That would prove to be the case, so on April 30th, the league announced the cancellation of the season.

The Aftermath: Contained in the press release cancelling the season was a precursor announcement of a potential, one-off, fall season. This would be challenging, with the large amount of college players that participate in the league, but it certainly kept up hopes that amatuer women’s soccer would be seen in 2020. However, much like the NPSL, the league decided to keep the now cancelled 2020 season fees, $3,500 per club, but offering only $1,000 credit for 2021 (or the potential fall league). Unlike the NPSL, Sean Jones got ahead of this story and gave the logic and reasoning behind the decision, which staunched the bleeding a bit.

Better, but not perfect - kept in front of the story, prepped a fan pleaser, did damage control. All in all, a mixed bag.

How it Happened: The UWS was great at keeping their clubs updated on the situation. Kudos on that. The league ran the clock out on this one, hoping to find a way to fit in a season. On March 12th, the league continued to plan on a season. On the 20th, the announced that the schedule would be adjusted. On April 4th, the league announced they still intended to play a 2020 season. However, on June 9th, the season was called and the league announced the regular 2020 season wasn’t going to happen. They just announced (June 12th) the UWS National Cup. As of today, seven teams are participating and the tournament will be hosted in Texas by FC Austin Elite.

The Aftermath: The big benefit of waiting until the last possible moment to cancel the season was that the UWS had learned from the missteps made by the other national amateur leagues. Every league that had given severely limited credit had been raked over the coals on social media. UWS, in a move their own press release called “bucking the trend,” the league announced they would be giving their clubs “approximately 80% credit towards next season’s fees.” And don’t think that last line of the press release isn’t an invite to other amatuer woso clubs “United Women’s Soccer looks forward to returning even stronger in 2021 with a full season of high level competition.”

I have two major complaints. One is that the league could have shown more leadership in cancelling the season earlier. Felt like it dragged out about two weeks longer than it should have. The other complaint is the inherent risks that come with playing soccer without the payroll to establish strong safety protocols with rigorous testing.

Close, very close - good communication, learned from other leagues’ mistakes, took care of clubs. Should have called it earlier.

How it Happened: The UPSL has, at times, struggled in moving with agility in public relations. I say this as a guy who emails the league looking for information on the regular. They are polite, but I’m almost always told, “we’re working on that.”

The league announced they would postpone the season on March 25th, using similar logic to the NPSL. The date the UPSL gave was May 2nd, which many scoffed at for being way too early for resuming play. Then an announcement came out on May 15th that league play would resume, in limited scope, on June 20th. Some states won’t allow play at this point, so those clubs won’t be participating. However, league powerhouse states like Florida and Texas, with governors set on reopening the economy, would be up and running. The league did stipulate that “The intention is to run a 10-game regular season ending the weekend of August 22-23 followed by two weekends of play-off competition, the second of those being Regional Finals on the weekend of September 5-7. Once participating divisions and teams are known, the play-off structure and season schedule will be released. This will occur no later than Thursday, June 11.”

The Aftermath: And this is the big gamble that I’ve discussed on at least 4 podcasts at this point. What happens if there’s a team infection scenario? Or if a player potentially dies from this? Or a fan gets sick from attending a match? Unlike the big professional leagues, the UPSL can’t have the same level of safety protocols. It’s a gamble, but will it pay off. That remains to be seen.

We just don’t know yet. Good communication, but with play about to resume, we shall see if the gamble pays off.

The NISA Season that Wasn't

 Note: This is for funzies, so take it with a grain of salt and a large alcoholic beverage. Or chocolate if you’re living a sober lifestyle.

 NISA’s 2020 Spring Season has been shut down, another sports league brought to a grinding halt by COVID-19. We’ll never know how it would have played out. Frustrating, I know. And in frustration, perhaps you shout out something like…

 “Isn’t there anyone who can tell me who would have taken the NISA trophy this spring?”

“Sure – I can tell you who would have taken the NISA trophy this spring.”

Lights, please.

And yes, those are clouds. We are heading into a dream sequence, so keep your arms inside the vehicle until the ride comes to a complete stop.

Going by the alphabet, let’s start with Cal United Strikers. With plenty of firepower, aggressive midfield play, and a solid, competent backline, Cal United would find a way to struggle every week. Enough results would go their way, yet at times they could frustrate the heck out of you. During one of these performances against LA Force, the usually happy and joyful play-by-play voice of the Strikers Simon Allen loses it in midstream, runs onto the field and starts yelling maniacally at the Cal United forwards, “Surely he’s going to shoot now! SURELY HE’S GOING TO SHOOT NOW!” The ref finally stopped play and surely showed Allen a red card. 

Chattanooga FC enjoyed a very sold first season as a professional club. Staying in the top half of the table for most of the spring season, playing in front of crowds that most lower league teams would be jealous of, CFC would punch a ticket to a playoff spot with a home win over 1904 FC. Good times, right? So why were the locals annoyed? In a word: Nashville hot chicken. OK, three words. If the members of the Chattanooga faithful got a nickel for every time visiting fanbases asked where to get the best hot chicken, they would hate the Red Wolves just as much (hah – didn’t see that coming, did ya?),  

Just fill in any gaps with imaginary friends. (Image courtesy of Youtube)

So yeah - Detroit City FC won lots of games, ran away from the rest of the league, blah de blahblahblah.  The more interesting aspect of the Spring Season was in the stands at Keyworth. Limited by a seating capacity of just under 8,000, the Northern Guard schemed up a way to increase this number: imaginary friends. First it was Invite an Imaginary Friend Night. Then those imaginary friends brought their friends. And so on. And so on. When the announced attendance was 27,394 for the Cal United Strikers game, things had gotten pretty weird – even by Northern Guard standards. So the decision was made to ban imaginary friends for the rest of the season. A few invisible tears were shed.   

So the LA Force crowds were practicing social distancing long before COVID-19, evidently. I know – low-hanging fruit. But the club would struggle for points and fans in stands during the spring season. And that’s a shame, because this is how many fans of lower league soccer want to see clubs built – from the ground up. This is an academy club that added a pro team at the top. The hope here is that the club can develop a following of a corps of passionate fans that can spread the word. Hey – they’re not all going to be funny.   

The Michigan Stars would continue to be a collective pain in the butt to play against, challenging offenses with their ability to take away each team’s best players. When Cal United came to Pontiac, the Stars put three men on Christian Thierjung right from the first moment. No, not the start of the game – as soon as he got off the bus. And in the parking lot. And into the locker room. Thierjung never actually got onto the pitch, and the Stars went with the rarely-used 7-1-0 lineup. But Cal United could only manage a nil-nil draw, as Gustavo Villalobos was swallowed up by Zanin Mahic’s hair.   

Only the first of many moments that ended up on tshirts.

Laney College Stadium would finally become that fortress for the Oakland Roots, and the club would make any opponent’s trip to Oakland a tough one. The road would cause some issues, but the club would keep themselves in the top half of the table throughout the spring. And the quick release of T-shirts to capture celebrated moments (like the Jack McInerney game-tying goal on opening night) would continue. A Matt Fondy wonderstrike against Detroit City – on a T-shirt. Taylor Bailey saves to PK against Cal United – on a T-shirt. Ariel Mbumba being subbed on in the 67th minute against LA Force – on a T-shirt. David Abdor taking a point blank shot to his junk – considered, but ultimately not on a T-shirt.

 The move from San Diego State’s stadium to Lincoln High School did not have the effect that 1904 FC – sorry, Ought Four – wanted as far as crowd support. As the season went on, the club would try different venues to get that intimate feel. Local parks. Parking lots. Mini golf courses. Against the Michigan Stars, they tried playing in a bowling alley. Didn’t manage much on the scoreboard (Tito Ramirez was bottled up at the snack bar by the Stars defense), but midfielder Christian Enriquez did bowl an impressive 187. Through it all, the Black Plague kept the faith - except when Enriquez missed an easy spare in the 9th frame. That almost broke them. 

In Stumptown, chasing a playoff spot would be a constant throughout the season. It would ultimately be not in the cards for the club, but they would be there right to the end. A home-and-home series with Detroit City to end the season would be Stumptown’s undoing. But here was one other storyline that hung over the season: the progress of the building behind one of the goals at OrthoCarolina Soccer Complex. When the Michigan Stars arrived, the siding had been completed. By the time of the Cal United game, some landscaping had been placed. Things looked good. Then came the Detroit City game, and an errant shot from George Chomakov sailed over the fence, crashed through an upper-story window, and blasted a hole through the roof. Deemed unfit to occupy, the building was razed – with new construction to start at the beginning of the fall season.

When the season ended in June, the table stood thusly:

Team                            Pts

Detroit City FC              987

Cal United Strikers         34

Chattanooga FC             31

Oakland Roots SC          29

Stumptown Athletic        24

San Diego 1904 FC         18

Los Angeles Force          16

Michigan Stars FC            9

(My math is impeccable, by the way).

 Since Cal United had already qualified for the playoffs due to the Fall Showcase, they somehow ended up having to face off against themselves in the semi-finals – much to the chagrin of the Oakland Roots! And that chagrin found its way onto a T-shirt. Playing itself to a nil-nil draw, Cal United managed to get past themselves on penalties.

In the other semi-final, it was Detroit City and Chattanooga FC hooking up for tense battle between old NPSL rivals. Evenly played throughout the first half, things got unraveled in the second half when the Northern Guard started chanting “Where’s your hot chicken?” which seemed to unnerve CFC. The floodgates opened, and DCFC was going to the finals!

Now it was down to Detroit City and Cal United. And in the final, the Strikers would pass and move with a veracity and determination that was impressive and almost led to a goal. But the final whistle would come, and both teams were without a goal. Extra time would be needed. For the Northern Guard, this meant extra extra smoke. A billowy blast would emanate from the stands, and slowly cover the entire field. Nobody could see a damned thing. Industrial fans would quickly be brought in to blow the smoke off the field. And when order was restored – the NISA trophy had disappeared!

Who’s laughing now? (image courtesy of Forbes.com)

Suddenly, the sound of wheels peeling out could be heard as a black limousine sped away. And leaning out the back window, Rocco Commisso held out the trophy, laughing.

So who took the NISA trophy? The New York Cosmos, of course.  

- John Howard-Fusco

If you enjoyed John’s approach to NISA in this article, you should check out his NISA podcast, the Knights Who Say NISA - available on the Protagonist Podcast feed on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever else you get podcasts.

NISA Postpones League Play for 30 Days

In a statement just released from the league:

The National Independent Soccer Association is committed the health and safety of the fans of the League as well as the players, staff members and communities. In light of the issues created by the outbreak of COVID-19 (Coronavirus Disease 2019), the League Office and its Board of Governors are suspending the season for the next 30 days effective immediately.

NISA will use this time to monitor this situation in consultation with medical experts and in consideration of the guidelines being put forth by local governments, public health officials and the CDC to determine next steps for moving forward with safe protocol.

We are committed to to being as transparent as possible as this rapidly evolving situation develops and more information becomes available. At the appropriate time, we will provide updates and plans for the continuation of the 2020 Spring Season. We wish everyone health and wellness.

This is a developing story.

The Risk of Soccer in the Age of COVID-19

Sports and Sickness

News broke today that the NCAA plans to hold its men’s and women’s tournaments without fans present due to the risk of COVID-19 transmission. The virus, commonly referred to as the Coronavirus, is considered too much of a threat for the NCAA to allow fans to attend the games. NCAA President Mark Emmert’s statement was very specific about the NCAA Board of Governors’ concerns. “I have made the decision to conduct our upcoming championship events, including the Division I men’s and women’s basketball tournaments, with only essential staff and limited family attendance. While I understand how disappointing this is for all fans of our sports, my decision is based on the current understanding of how COVID-19 is progressing in the United States. This decision is in the best interest of public health, including that of coaches, administrators, fans and, most importantly, our student-athletes.”

The announcement from the NCAA came in tandem with an announcement from Ohio Governor Mike DeWine banning spectators from games, specifically the NCAA Men’s tournament kickoff game to be played in Dayton. “The order will be that there cannot be spectators there. There certainly will be people — there will be TV people, there can be radio people there, there can be sports writers, certainly can be the media there. But we’re not going to have the large crowd.” In another statement DeWine was blunt about his perspective - “Ohioans have to understand what the facts are, that any gathering of people in close proximity to each other is dangerous.” DeWine’s announcement is one in a series of large-scale bans being implemented by local municipalities in the face of the rapidly spreading pandemic. Schools across the country have either cancelled classes or moved classes online, in an effort to slow the progress of the disease.

Soccer Reacts

The soccer world in other countries is ramping up their efforts to curtail the spread of COVID-19, particularly in Italy, where matches have been played in front of empty seats. La Liga officials made the aggressive decision to suspend the league for the rest of the month, in hopes of the situation coming under control by early April. In the United States, Seattle Sounders, in a state heavily affected by the outbreak, just announced the postponement of their next home game, due to a request from the governor. The USL affiliate of the Sounders, Tacoma Defiance, will play their next match behind closed doors.

So where does that leave the subject of our coverage, the grassroots soccer leagues across the country? We’ve reached out to several of the leagues we cover and only the UPSL has responded officially. A spokesperson for the league gave this statement: “The UPSL is staying flexible but following USASA guidance on this. That said, games are currently scheduled to be played this weekend.” We left a message at the USASA National Office for Duncan Riddle, executive director, but haven’t heard back at the time of publication (should he respond, this article will be updated).

The NPSL, for their part, sent out a memo to their clubs which included a statement from Cindy Spera, NPSL Managing Director, “With the increase of reported CoVid-19 (“coronavirus”) around the country, our main priority is the safety and health of our players, coaches, and staff.  Our 2020 NPSL season has started matches on the West coast, and nationally, our teams are preparing for US Open Cup and holding tryouts and pre-season training sessions.  We would like to recommend that our teams adopt best practices in order to minimize the chance of exposure.” Included with this memo was a list of potential approaches clubs could take to limit risk. While there was a general section on general approaches, there was also a section for soccer specific approaches which included:

• Anyone (player, staff member, coach, etc.) who is feverish should not participate and stay at home.

• Avoid handshakes - use fist bumps or elbow touches with players, coaches, staff, and referees.

• Avoid all spitting - including on the ground as players may come in contact. Coaches should remind players not to spit. 

• Ensure that athletic trainers are prompt to give them extra time to address any concerns. 

• Ensure that trainers have adequate supplies - especially gloves and antibacterial supplies such as sanitizer, alcohol pads, and soap products. 

• Have extra balls on hand.  If a ball goes into the stands, disinfect the ball before putting it back in play.  The home team is advised to wipe down balls with alcohol or disinfectant at half time.

• Suspend autograph signings as it is a risk to pass items back and forth.

• Display attached sign / infographic in your training facility on game day in locker rooms, bathrooms, and food areas.

The sign mentioned in the final item is a sign that MLS created for their clubs. The NPSL received permission to include and post the sign for their players and staff.

MLS-created content.

The Difficult, but Right Path

It seems clear that banning large gatherings of people makes sense, especially when we think of the potential contact each attendee could have in their everyday lives. While most adults and children are relatively safe in the event of infection, there is still a statistical chance of serious illness or death. And for older adults (70+) or those with compromised immune systems, the threat is much more serious and often fatal. No person should ignore the risk to those of our community that could not survive this disease, regardless of their own health. Everyone has a grandmother, grandfather, or some other family member or friend who could run the risk of death, should they become infected with COVID-19.

So should leagues cancel matches or play the matches without a viewing audience? It seems obvious they should do something aggressive, particularly when members of the crowd could run the risk of infecting each other. Obviously in some regional or local leagues, crowds aren’t really a concern, but even the players may run the risk of infection. The virus is still contagious even before symptoms begin to manifest, so a player may not feel sick on matchday even though they could be infecting those around. Luckily, most of the NPSL and UPSL aren’t playing league matches yet, leaving the league the chance to wait and see. However, in those leagues most of California is already up and rolling and NISA is already in Week 3 of action this weekend, with important home openers scheduled in Chattanooga and Detroit in the next couple of weeks, where large crowds should be expected. With streaming via Youtube or Mycujoo easily accessible for their fans to watch the matches, why run the risk of spreading the disease?

Dealing with a public health threat requires concern, intelligence, scientific facts, and a willingness to sacrifice. It seems clear that now is the time to take drastic steps, but rather or not teams and leagues will take those steps remains to be seen. Fans will certainly be opposed to any action that restricts their access to their clubs, but doing what’s best for the weakest in our society is the most important decision any league or organization could make. Either postpone the games or restrict access and stream the matches, it’s the right thing to do at this important moment.

- Dan Vaughn

When we hear back from any official, we’ll update this article.

Dan Watches NISA: Week Two

Each week, I’ll be writing a recap of the NISA matches, give my thoughts on the matches and give a short power ranking of the clubs at the end. All matches were watched on Mycujoo, because I don’t live within 500 miles of any NISA clubs. Matches will be in random order.

Week 2 in the books. Two draws and a win, there’s going to be weeks like this in any league. Certainly hard to match the intensity and excitement of week 1, especially with Chattanooga and DCFC on bye weeks. But we’ll soldier on! Time to look at the matches of week 2.

---

LA Force 1 - Stumptown 1

• A note on officials - Has anyone noticed how many women officials there have been in these matches? Three matches tonight and two of them had head officials that were women and (at least) one had a woman as a side judge. I haven’t heard any specific talk about this from the league and maybe it’s just a coincidence, but this is a great move on the part of the league. Honestly, they should be trumpeting it. And, as my podcast cohost John would say “if you aren’t noticing the officials, they’re doing a good job.” So far so good!

• It’s clear to me that Stumptown is taking the “fire at will” approach early in matches. Long shots, yards outside of the box, are flying in both their matches so far this season. Funny enough their goal this match was more build up play, but they are definitely trying to test the keeper early and often AND from distance.

• Pitch notes - this match had the best looking rug of the evening. Oakland has that patchwork abomination they bought and 1904 FC is playing on a football field. Yikes.

1904 FC 0 - Cal United Strikers FC 0

• There are different kinds of draws. There are the kind where both teams score goals and end up even at the end of the match. There are the kind where the keepers stone their opponents and it ends in a stalemate. Then there are the kind where the viewers are bored out of their minds the entire match…

• Cal United looked flat this match, especially compared to Week 1. Not sure if the hour commute really wore them out, but they looked disinterested and slow, almost as bored as I was watching the match. I kept waiting to see the slick passes and smooth interchange between players of Week 1 and the club looked zombie-like instead. Just not there in the way I expected. They could have won this match and left one on the table. Hope it doesn’t bite them in the ass at the end of the season.

• Oh, but 1904 woke up in extra time. Suddenly all the pressure in the world was coming from San Diego. I guess they were well rested from being so slow and disengaged all match? They looked dangerous and aggressive in the few minutes of extra time, in a way they hadn’t looked the entire match. More of that please, 1904!

Oakland Roots 2 - Michigan Stars 1

• I’ve said it multiple times already, but Stars deserve more points than the goose egg they are sitting on right now. They’ve played long stretches of punishing, patient defense, and each match they’ve conceded and lost the match. You work that hard, you deserve more credit and certainly a point or two.

• Jack McInerney continues to be the most dangerous man in NISA. 8 goals in 8 matches. He could have gotten two more than his lone goal in this match. He had one called back for offsides (debatable) and a second went off the crossbar. I’ll predict it now, barring some crazy matches from another player, JackMac will end the season as the golden boot winner.

• First win for Oakland. Big deal. Glad they didn’t blow it in the final minutes.

• Michigan Stars looked downright threatening in the second half. Scoring chances, good passing, and all without their defense falling apart. I think it might be time to rethink their bunkering strategy and look for something more balanced. They have the attacking talent on the roster, let those horses run.

That’s it for this week. Check out our Protagonist Podcast feed on almost every major podcast outlet, brand new episode of Knights Who Say NISA out Monday night. Every match recapped and broken down by Dan Vaughn and John Howard-Fusco.

- Dan Vaughn

The Only Time We'll Interview a 15-year Old

Shane Kaemerle subbed on for Cal United Strikers FC against Michigan Stars FC two weekends ago. A big moment for anyone, playing for a pro side in a brand new league, but for a 15-year old it’s a life changer. When we heard his story, we had to sit down and talk with him, a boy among men.

So 15, huh? When I was that age, I just played a lot of video games. What electronic games do you waste time on?

I play a lot of FIFA and Fortnite with my friends 

Can you talk about your path through the Cal United system? How long have you been involved with the club?

I have been involved for 7 months. I came out during the summer 3-4 Times a week which transitioned into me practicing full time with the club and now I am where I am

Impressive to see you make your pro debut with Strikers two weeks ago. What was that feeling like, subbing in against Michigan Stars?

It was amazing, I was pretty nervous at the beginning but as soon as I stepped foot on the field all of those nerves went away. 

Speaking of Stars, saw one player get a pretty good tackle against you. Was that your welcome to the pros moment?

Yeah, I think so, he came up to me after the game and told me that was my “welcome to the pros” 

What approach do you take, playing against 20 and 30 year olds?

I definitely have to adapt my game and play quicker because they’re a lot stronger and faster. It’s much different than playing against academy players. 

What do you think of your club's chances in NISA this season?

I think we have a great group of players and a great team and I think we will be bringing home that cup this season. 

What's your relationship like with your fellow Strikers? Anyone mentor you specifically?

My relationship is good with everyone on the team, but Kevin Jeon and Chris Klute have been big mentors for me by giving me pointers and helping me understand the game more. 

What role do you expect to play this season?

I hope to play as many minutes as I can, but my focus is to make it into the 18 each game and work myself into the lineup when they need me. 

What are your long-term goals in soccer?

My long term goal is to go to Europe and fight for a spot there. For now though I am focusing on this goal, with Cal United, to help the team to a championship. 

What music do you listen to hype up before a match?

I listen to mainly rap, Playboy Carty is my jam. 

What's the best part of being a 15 year old pro?

I get to play the sport I love for a living! I don’t have the traditional school experience, but I wouldn’t change that for anything.

How do your parents feel about you playing soccer with adults?

They’re very excited for me. My dad thinks this is the best thing for me right now to be with Cal United and grow my game. He played himself, and so for him to be able to see me grow in this sport right here in my backyard is a huge plus. 

NISA Week 2 Preview

John Howard-Fusco is half of the Knights Who Say NISA podcast. He dug into the upcoming weekend and has the preview of every match.

LA Force v Stumptown Athletic

Friday, 3/6 10:30PM ET

Jesse Owens Stadium, Cal State LA, Los Angeles CA

It’s an All-Cali Weekend as all three matches in NISA will be played on the left coast. LA Force is once again hosting some Friday night footy, with Stumptown Athletic making its first cross-country journey. The home team needs to find some offense, and possibly a few more fans in the stands. Facing Detroit City FC in its opening match was a tall order, but LA Force showed some capacity to press and create chances.

Stumptown demonstrated some offensive prowess in its opening draw with 1904 FC and look to continue their scoring ways. The midfield earned both goals last week, between Tate Robertson’s wonder strike off a free kick from distance and pacy Jalen Brown delivering the other.

Should Stumptown come away with a result, we must give this club some early consideration for being a potential playoff candidate.        

Oakland Roots v Michigan Stars FC

Saturday, 3/7 8:10PM ET

Laney College Football Stadium, Oakland CA

The Roots played a rock-‘em, sock-‘em 1-1 draw with Chattanooga FC last weekend, the highlight match of NISA’s opening card of games. And while Michigan Stars may not be the same level of opponent, their defense will deliver plenty of rock-‘em and sock-‘em. It will be interesting to see how the capacity home crowd will react to seeing their local lads get a little roughed up.

In comparison to last week’s game, don’t expect the same back and forth kind of action from Oakland. Expect Michigan to bog down the middle and look to counter. But with a poacher like Jack McInerney, the Roots may only need one chance to break through.   

The Roots produced a limited-edition T-shirt celebrating McInerney’s game-tying goal from last week. Just imagine what will happen if they win a game. This is the game they need to win.

1904 FC v Cal United Strikers FC

Sunday, 3/8 8PM ET

Lincoln High School, San Diego CA

Fifteen goals given up in six games during the fall, 1904 gave up two more in the opener against Stumptown Athletic. So who’s coming to the club’s home opener? Why, it’s Gustavo Villalobos, Christian Thierjung et al from Cal United – the club that handed Ought Four losses of 3-0 and 4-1 last fall. Yikes.

The good news is that it is 1904’s home opener, and playing their home games at Lincoln High School’s field should help create a more lively atmosphere. Will it help in the win column? That all depends if the club can do a similar job in slowing down Cal United that Michigan Stars did last week. It says here that’s not likely to happen.

With back-to-back games against 1904, along with Detroit City FC having two weeks off, Cal United has a chance to be the spring season’s early pace setters.

Old Man Yells at Sky: Enough NISA Already!

1. So NISA, huh? - NISA fever is sweeping the country and no amount of CDC warnings are gonna stop it. Ok, maybe that’s an exaggeration, but the truth is if you watched the week 1 matches, there is a lot going on in this league to be excited about. The clubs are solid on the field, some are downright great, the broadcasts have been good so far, the league seems to be shaping up, and don’t forget, next season we see even more sides hopping in, including NY Cosmos. Sort of wish Miami FC hadn’t pulled the plug on their NISA launch, but whatever, enjoy being the 10th-12th ranked club in USL-C.

2. Icarus is the gem of lower league soccer kits. - So many beautiful kits coming out of the genius mind of Robby Smuckler. I don’t know when, in his trajectory, that I met him, but every interaction with the guy has been top notch, class. I don’t understand why more clubs aren’t working with him, he’s simply the best. Every time I see another bland, generic kit I think, why didn’t you call Icarus?

3. NPSL regular season is underway, huh? - Yeah, the southwest clubs are already at it in the NPSL, way before we see the rest of the league kick off. Can’t express it enough, this is not a positive thing. It leads to all sorts of imbalance and gaps at the end of the season. Standardize the start times, guys! It would be better for everyone involved, OR have a smaller league with multiple tiers. It doesn’t make sense that Napa Valley kicked off their season last weekend and MPLS City’s opener is MAY 16th. That’s a full 2 months from now. What the hell.

4. Anyone else see that mock up of if Hummel made MPLS City’s kits? - @KonceptKitz is a handle out of England that focuses on football kits and reimagined MPLS City kits if Hummel had done them. mmmmmm. Yeah. Not good, Bob. If any club nails their kits, it’s MPLS City. Hummel would have generated some boring ass kits, apparently.

5. Picking up my Locomotive season tickets today. - Yeah, I’m a shill and a traitor.

6. Chipotle. Really? - Chipotle is now “the official Mexican restaurant” of US Soccer. How hilarious that a place that doesn’t serve real Mexican food is the official Mexican food of a plastic organization like US Soccer (which is so little dedicated to actual soccer). So maybe it’s the perfect fit? Also 9 times out of 10 I get a stomach ache from consuming what they are serving?

   On a side note, I’m glad they are picking up sponsors, but wish they’d focus on building up the talent development.

7. Politics - If you follow me on social media, you know I’m very into politics and have strong takes on pretty much everything political. We may not agree, but I feel strongly about things and express myself. I’m very left leaning. I’m a Bernie guy, without the shitty aggressiveness online to people with different opinions. Just as in 2016, super Tuesday has left me really disappointed with many of my fellow voters. Especially after recently coming back from Europe, seeing so many amazing things that a country can do for its citizens if it wants to put its money where its mouth is. Instead, in the United States we whine about costs, cut taxes on the rich, cut social programs, and let our weak and mentally unstable wander the streets. Sigh.

8. OVPL expands into WOSO. - I’m glad, but are they growing faster than sustainable? Feels like it, but I don’t want to be THAT GUY. I am that guy. Patience, people. You’ll dominate the world someday, but today is not that day. I wish them well though!

9. Las Vegas Lights, corny on purpose - When I write these columns, I like to scroll through my twitter feed and find subjects based on what’s going on. LVL is always there and usually I ignore them, but today I wanted to make a point. I think they have the most overrated, ugly kits in the game, that their mascot is moronic, and their marketing is shitty. And you know what, it’s perfect for their hometown. It’s not about a one size fits all approach, it’s about finding what works for your fanbase and doing that. Be you, LVL.

10. Music: “My Companjera” - Gogol Bordello. If you haven’t listened to this “gypsy punk” band, I’d really suggest it. Great band full of international influence without the general douchiness that comes with “international music.” Fantastic music.

DCFC Making Friends on the Road

The quest to find fans and convert disinterested people to true believers is the key to survival in grassroots soccer. Soccer fans are a subset of sports fandom in this country and the field is full of rival clubs, both foreign and domestic. Every supporter group member and player is an ambassador for your club and how they represent themselves can ensure the long-term stability of the organization. And last weekend, Laura Horah became a fan of Detroit City FC.

The story popped up on twitter and was too good to not follow. Laura posted a response to a Detroit City FC post about meeting the club in the hotel they were both staying at.  We reached out for more of the background.

Laura was travelling on business and happened to share the hotel with the Detroit City players who were in town for their match with LA Force. Laura isn’t exactly a soccer fan. When we asked if she followed soccer or DCFC prior to this weekend, she was blunt. “I do not and did not know anything about them prior to this hotel stay.” She happened to spot all the young men wearing Detroit City jackets and her interest was piqued.

I am staying in your hotel and have chatted with a few of you in the elevator and breakfast area. You are all such polite and friendly young men. Your parents should be super proud! Congrats on your win too!

— Laura Jane (@LJHorah) February 29, 2020

“One of the players was in the coffee area trying to determine the various types of coffee being served. I pointed out the Hazelnut, regular and decaffeinated. He asked me what decaffeinated meant and I explained it was coffee without caffeine. I then said ‘I don't know why anyone would even bother drinking coffee without caffeine’ and he said the same thing. He was looking for real coffee like I was. I wished him a nice day and he did the same and thanked me.”

Laura’s dog, Cessna

The next day, as Laura and her husband were trying to make the elevator, “Several players were in that left elevator and yelled out to us, holding the door for us and telling us there was room. I believe George Chomakov and Matt Lewis were two of those players. I think there were 3 or 4 total? I thanked them for holding the door open. We were dressed for exercising and one of them (George I think) asked us if we were headed to work out. I said yes and that we needed to do something to help with the breakfasts they had been serving. He agreed. I asked him when their game was (I said game but I think it's called match, as I now know!) and he said it had been the prior night and that they had won. I told them congratulations. They seemed very excited about the win.”

When she got back to her room, she decided to do some investigating. “Out of curiosity I looked up the team online when I got back to the hotel later that morning. I wanted to reach out because we rarely get anything positive news-wise. Athletes, as well as others in the public eye, are often described as rude and entitled. I have heard all kinds of horror studies. My interactions with this team were so positive I thought it might be nice for them to be recognized in some fashion.”

And now, Laura, who seems like the nicest person on twitter (you can see how cute her dog is), is a fan of the club. “I definitely will. I now know their games are streaming and I plan to check them out. I am a big sports fan so I will add this to my list and will always consider Detroit City FC my favorite soccer team!”

You never know who you are holding the elevator for, maybe it’s your next biggest fan!

- Dan Vaughn

Dan Creel's Quick Hits on NISA 2020

Yesterday, NISA announced the home openers for its spring 2020 season. Some thoughts:

• It’s nice to see they are naming the competition a “season”. Last year, the league went out of its way to not call the fall series of games either a season or bunch of exhibitions. They branded it a Showcase and, throughout the fall, tip-toed a fine marketing line between making it seem important enough to be a season but not *that* important.

• Where’s the full schedule? Home openers are great, but it feels like the league needed to get something out there even though they have a lot of things still up in the air.

• Where’s 1904 FC’s home opener? LA Force is hosting the first game of the season at historic TBD Oval and they even have a home opener scheduled.

• Full schedule is promised to be “revealed” in a couple weeks “featuring its full roster of clubs.” I read that as there are more clubs involved in the spring season than those listed in the home opener media release. If so, again, a bit troubling, that “clubs to be named later” is still a thing when the league announces its home openers and only six weeks before the season starts. Who are these unnamed clubs? Why aren’t they listed in any of the home openers?

• Philadelphia Fury and/or Atlanta S.C. are still prominently featured on NISA’s site at the time of the media release. Philly folded after playing one NISA Showcase match in the Fall. Atlanta has been holding tryouts per its Twitter account but it’s gone silent as of December 27 and the team’s website is gone. Neither club is listed on the new NISA standings page.

• Are they still in the mix? To be honest, it’s worrying if they are and worrying if they aren’t. If they are, it doesn’t feel like the clubs and league have their act together this close to the new season. If they aren’t then, it’s a bit shady to hint at other clubs. Even if there are other clubs about to join, the practical logistics of getting pro teams up and running in such a short time does the league, the other clubs and their fans a disservice.

• A quick historical aside: a big reason why the old American Soccer League collapsed in 1983 was because the league rules allowed a club to let its league franchise go dormant while still having member voting power in league matters. This gave a lot of power to a number of members who no longer had active teams in the league. Those members still held franchise rights over numerous territories and were able to get financially advantageous decisions for themselves to the detriment of the league. I’m hoping that a similar situation isn’t at work with NISA.

• NISA is touting the spring season as a single table format. Now, while I think that’s the best format for any league, I’m concerned that’s going to create a lot of cross country travel. And, that’s going to mean a huge travel bill for each club. That’s costly for any top-level sports team. But, it’s a ton of weight for any Division 3 operation to bear. I would have prefered the league split into two regions with each region playing a single table round robin. There are historical concerns showing that new pro leagues, and especially the clubs in those leagues, buckle and fail due to the amount of expenses necessary to play nationally.

• The playoffs are fine, but Cal United gets the #1 seed because they won the West playoff game last fall? That’s a big benefit for winning a playoff game during a competition that won’t be nearly as tough as the spring season itself. Plus, if Cal United sucks in the Spring, the #4 seed ends up getting a better seeding than top two spring teams. US soccer fans hate when uneven playoffs negate a regular season.

• Bottom line, the NISA home opener release is fine. But, I expect more and NISA has a lot to prove. I want the league to do well and, even more than that, I want the clubs to do well. The league has a duty to take care of the great clubs now taking part in its competition. Because of that, I’m going to continue holding them to a high standard that the US soccer community deserves.

  - Dan Creel

Ranking the NISA Home Openers

For those that missed it, NISA put out a list of the home openers for the Spring 2020 season. With the first match kicking off on the weekend of February 29, we’re sitting 6 weeks out from the kick-off of the expanded season of NISA play with the addition of Chattanooga, Detroit City, and Michigan Stars. The full schedule won’t be released until later this month, so for now, let’s rank the home openers.

- Dan

---

★

Stumptown Athletic vs. 1904 FC (2/29/20)

Stumptown Athletic was the runner up in the East to Miami FC, but with Philly Fury forfeiting the season and Atlanta SC’s 2 wins coming in matches that Philly vacated, they have a tremendous amount to prove heading into this season. The addition of heavy hitters in the East will mean that task will be even harder. 1904 only managed two wins in the stronger West and will be desperate to start off their season with a win. This will be a match most will skip out on and, with Stumptown’s attendance issues last season, the stands will reflect that.

★★

Cal United Strikers FC vs. Michigan Stars FC (2/29/20)

This isn’t going to come as a surprise to anyone familiar with the NPSL, Michigan Stars was the little brother in a conference dominated by big name clubs, including their fellow NISA expansion, DCFC. Stars have a lot to prove in their league and will have to kick off their season on the road, heading to Orange County to face Cal United Strikers. Strikers finished the last regular season in second position in the standings. They followed that up by beating LA in the playoffs on PKs. Kicking off their season against an unproven NISA expansion side should be a recipe for a quick 3 points.

Chattanooga FC vs. Michigan Stars FC (3/14/20)

CFC is one of two big names to cross over into NISA during the offseason. With their ability to fill Finley, it’s reasonable to expect a crazy crowd for this first professional match for Chatta. The club should make quick work of their fellow ex-Members Cup opponent. Speaking of Members Cup, Michigan finished with only 2 wins and a negative 8 goal differential. Not good, man.

★★★

Michigan Stars FC vs. Los Angeles Force (3/21/20)

So I’ve dunked on Michigan Stars in two previous previews, so let’s give this home opener a 3 star rating. I’d expect the club to be on a losing streak and this will be a chance to bounce back, facing a club that had to travel over 2,000 miles. Is anyone else a little troubled the match is scheduled at a location TBD? Seems a little late in the game for details like that to not be settled. Anyway, back to the match, so good chance for a bounce back for the hosts, EXCEPT their opponent was the regular season champ in the West and lost on PKs in the playoffs. LA Force will have faced DCFC at home for their opener (more on that later) and we don’t know the rest of the schedule yet, but without a doubt this appears on paper to be a big win opportunity for LA.

★★★★

Detroit City FC vs. Oakland Roots (3/21/20)

Detroit City FC heads into NISA with a ton of steam after soundly defeating the rest of the Members Cup participants in the Fall. Detroit really matched their support and swagger with solid play on the field and look to be the favorites of this first season in NISA. Their first NISA opponent at Keyworth will be Oakland Roots, a club that nailed every aspect of their rollout in 2019, except for their on-field play. With a new coach and a renewed roster, Oakland will be looking to match their looks with substance in 2020.

Oakland Roots vs. Chattanooga FC (2/29/20)

Everything I said about Oakland in the previous preview, but now they get to host the other big boy expansion club, Chattanooga FC. It’s a long trip from Chattanooga, so maybe that helps Oakland? Especially considering Oakland draws well, something that CFC rarely has rarely seen outside of Detroit. I think this match is sneaky good and should show us where Oakland is headed into 2020.

★★★★★

Los Angeles Force vs. Detroit City FC (2/29/20)

Yet another match to be played at TBD, but WHAT a match. The 2019 regular season winner from the West hosts the bad boys of Detroit on the first week of the 2020 season. This should bring all the eyes on opening weekend. Circle this match.

Oakland first, always.

Nominated for Protagonist Club of the Year, Oakland Roots showed from day one their ability to connect with their city and its fans in ways that most grassroots clubs haven’t. We sat down with Edreece Arghandiwal, club cofounder, CMO, and one of the primary drivers of the young club’s branding. With year one in the books, Arghandiwal opened up about the club, their first year successes, and how Oakland will remain the primary focus in every decision moving forward.

---

First season in the can, what went right? What could you have done better season one? 

2019 was a dream start for the Roots. People have asked us how we did it, and the answer is quite simple; Oakland did it. The Roots acted as a vehicle for the ideas, passion, and interest that already reside in our community. We not only sold out games, but were able to build an identity that is synonymous with Oakland. We had a team that represented the community, had incredible game day experiences, and built a safe place for people to just be themselves. There were many successes, but we will not stop there. I don’t think we will ever stop, because Oakland hasn’t ever stopped. Walt Disney said that Disneyland will never be done as long as there is an imagination. Roots aren’t quite Disneyland, but I hope you get the point. Diverse people, ideas, creativity, and culture exist in Oakland and as long as those things exist, we will always have to think differently. We are constantly looking at ways to challenge assumptions. We have an opportunity to do things the Oakland way. 

This past year, our team was left with one wish; to do even more in the place we love the most. 

What’s your favorite memory of this first season? 

At our first game, we shutdown East 10th street for a block party, and the response was overwhelming. We had local artists perform, food trucks serving food, good drinks from local breweries, and more. I remember being in the middle of the concert and hearing the chorus of one of the songs that was being performed, “O-O-O-O-Ohhh.” As I looked around I saw everyone throwing up an “O” for Oakland. I got emotional, and I won’t forget it ever. Our first ever game landed on my 30th birthday, so it was a perfect mesh of happenings. 

One of my favorite songs is Telegraph Ave. by Childish Gambino, and there is a part of the song where Gambino says “we’ll both be thirty soon in Oakland.” I always thought about the day I would turn 30 in Oakland, and it happened in a way that I could have never guessed. I am grateful. 

Jack McInerney was your 2019 offensive player of the year, how did having a player of his caliber on the club shape the offense this season? Will he be returning to the club next season? 

Jack is a helluva player and human being. His attitude and style scream Oakland, and we are blessed to have him in our group. We hope to see Jack return next season. Roster decision announcements will be made soon so stay tuned for those. 

Overall, the club was unable to get much momentum in the table in 2019. Did that play a role in the separation of Paul Bravo? Why was the decision made to move on? 

I will just point you towards the comment from our club President and my Co-Founder when the decision was made a month ago. “The entire front office is thankful for the work Paul put in to help build this team in the first season. He was a true professional throughout the year and is a pioneer for the Oakland Roots, join the club based on our vision. We wish Paul the best as he continues to serve the Bay Area soccer community with the De Anza Force and the California Thorns. He will always be a welcome member of this family.” 

Can you talk about the promotion of Jordan Ferrel and why he was the best candidate for your club? What are you expectations for his performance in the upcoming NISA season? 

I'll leave the roster and technical decisions to our technical staff, but I can say that we're excited to have Jordan Ferrell serve as our next head coach. Jordan has a lot of ties to this community, and he's a great choice to serve Oakland and lead our team. His passion and desire to see Oakland succeed is what makes this a perfect fit. 

The club drew well in your first season, how was that accomplished from a club-planned approach? 

Oakland has always had an appetite for the sport of soccer. It was only a matter of time for that craving to come to life. We wanted to build a club that embodied the principles of The Town. Oakland First, Always. This doesn’t have to mean you have to be from Oakland to be a fan of this team. “Oakland First, Always” means you appreciate and respect the arts, culture, and diversity. Roots is bigger than a club. It’s a movement, and a way of life. 

What approach does Oakland Roots take to maintain connection with the city and the fans? 

We listen, and we try to always live up to what we say. Being in Oakland means you have to be present. You have to listen, and you have to be about the action. You have to walk the walk in this city, and we plan to do just that. If we slip up along the way, I hope people hold us accountable. 

Our team made an effort to be at every major community event, not with the mission of converting folks to ticket buyers or season passes, but to genuinely connect and build commonalities. I am a believer in word-of-mouth marketing. People will spread the love, if they feel love. 

Early on we built a community advisory board of people that represented Oakland; the shakers and movers of our community. We rely on them to keep us on the right path. I am forever grateful for them. 

What’s in the works looking forward? 

As you might have seen we launched Project 51O a reserve team that will play in the NPSL and function as the clubs reserve team. A project is “an individual or collaborative enterprise that is carefully planned and designed to achieve a particular aim. For Roots, the aim is to help develop soccer and promote culture in the 51O. 

As much as the club has been about the team on the field, there’s been a tremendous amount of focus on brand identity. Can you talk about what went into that from a foundational perspective? What goals did you set for branding? 

Branding is not just about slapping a logo on a t-shirt. That’s the thing I hope people truly understand. A crest and an identity have to speak loudly about the people that wear it. It has to feel good associating with. Most importantly, it has to look good. Good design is a big part of our brand approach. We spent a lot of time developing our brand, because we care about it. Everything is done with intention...otherwise what’s the point? 

Several moodboards turned into think groups, and think groups turned into many crests. We landed on the crest because it embodied the color and diversity that exists in our community. The Oak Tree is a big part of the brand identity of the city, so it was a must-have on the crest. We want the crest and identity to be associated with city-pride, culture, arts, sports...LIFE. Soccer happens to be our vehicle, but Oakland Roots is a bigger idea. It’s a wave. 

Which gear-wearing celebrity thrilled you the most? 

Dame Dolla. Period. Dame is real Oakland. The man is genuine, cares about where he comes from, and is insanely humble despite the fame and fortune. You have to know where you come from in order to know where you are going. 

Can you talk about what makes Roots (as a brand), Oakland? What is Oakland style? 

Different. 

Looking towards Spring 2020, how can Roots continue the positive flow? What steps is the club taking to maintain momentum? 

Do more, do Oakland. Reach more people by spreading the message of love, community, and sports. 

Any potential friendlies on the horizon?

We are always looking at potential friendlies we can play but nothing to announce as of now on that front”

Club of the Year Nominee: Detroit City FC

In every industry, there’s a gold standard. Every competitor aims to replicate its success, to mirror results, to match the reputation, but the item that occupies that top spot is universally appreciated and admired. Even the haters and detractors throw their barbs with the knowledge they are doing it out of jealousy and they’d trade spots in a heartbeat, if they could. But no amount of wishing ever gets a thing to the apex position, instead it is achieved through hard work, dedication, passion, consuming ambition, fierce aggression, and a recognition that building something that will last will require massive amounts of sacrifice.

The history of the lower leagues is a bloodbath, awash with the corpses of thousands of clubs that have come and gone. Each year, clubs bow out of competitions and leagues, shut up shop and send out defeated emails to fans. It’s not the exception, but the rule in the current American landscape. Well-intentioned men and women have wasted millions of dollars and thousands of hours trying to create a lasting legacy of success for their club, only to watch the stands sit empty and the bill pile up, until eventually, emptied of resources and devoid of confidence, they give up. Sometimes it’s the plan, sometimes it’s finances, sometimes it’s the lack of fan support, sometimes it’s the players, sometimes sponsors can’t be found, and sometimes it just wasn’t meant to be.

To get to the mark of the gold standard, acts of faith and sacrifice are required. Honestly, there’s so much advice against trying it, most friends will have to be ignored. You’d be insane to believe you’re going to be the club which makes it. All of the facts tell any reasonable person to find something else to invest your time into. And the money, people have gone bankrupt doing this, throwing away retirement funds, burning bridges by borrowing operating expenses, maxing out credit cards in pursuit of the dream. None of it makes sense, but if you can push through, maybe you can climb the mountain of dead and failing clubs. That’s the dream anyway, that’s Detroit City FC.

Detroit City FC (DCFC) played its first season in the NPSL in 2012 and Alan Jacobson, a member of the Northern Guard Supporters Group (NGS), was there. Alan had watched other clubs try to connect with the city, but when he met Sean Mann, one of five DCFC owners, he sensed something different. “Sean made it clear that active support would not only be ok, it would be appreciated. The willingness to allow an organic culture to develop at DCFC is an example of the approach the team owners would take in terms of managing the team. As Sean has said in the past, they (the owners) are the “hosts of the party, not the stars of the party.” For a lot of people this was a big contrast to sporting events run by the big pro teams, where every game day element seems to be contrived and controlled.” Mark Navarro, a fellow member of NGS, seconded that idea of organic connection. “City stands out over other clubs because it genuinely cares about the community in which it plays and wants to see that community thrive, not just in soccer, but also in the well-being of the people who live there.”

Writing about DCFC without discussing the importance of NGS would be ignoring a primary part of what makes DCFC the gold standard. Lindsey Pehrson, DCFC Communication Director agrees. “Without Northern Guard, Detroit City FC wouldn't be what it is today. They are the life and soul of this club and they are largely the reason for the growth the club has experienced over the years. We are supporter built through and through.” Many clubs have attempted to replicate the connection between club and fan, but the organic symmetry between the club on the pitch and NGS in the stands is magic. The rising smoke of the flares, the screaming faces in the crowd, the banging of the drums, the club feeding off that energy on the field, there is nothing like it in ALL of American soccer.

Navarro highlights that feeling as contagious and bigger than soccer. “I’ve met many people in NGS who didn’t care about soccer until they came to a match and saw what NGS does. And, as a result, they’ve fallen in love with the club, which is our ultimate goal as a group. It’s about the environment: Not just the smoke and the drums and all of that, but the fact that all people--regardless of race, gender identity, sexuality, religion, citizenship status, political affiliations, or any other identities--are welcome into our section as long as they love City is vital.”

This year saw the culmination of 8 years of growth with the club announcing a move to NPSL Pro, then Members Cup, and eventually into NISA - DCFC would become fully professional. But the business of the NPSL saw the club win its division, before absolutely dominating the short but heavily stacked Members Cup lineup. Detroit lost a single match in the league, led by a stifling defense which only allowed 4 goals in 10 matches. The play on the field matched the passion of the crowds filling Keyworth Stadium. When asked what stood out, Pehrson listed off the accomplishments, “winning the NPSL Great Lakes Conference before hoisting the 2019 Members Cup championship, beating Atlas FC at home, going nine games unbeaten in 23 league games, etc. It's hard to boil it down to just one moment.” Pair that on the field success with the continued expansion of Detroit City Fieldhouse, a 75,000 square foot indoor multi-sport facility, and the announcement of the creation of a women’s side. 2019 was a ringing success for Le Rouge.

Every club in the country would do anything to have what DCFC has, few are willing to work as hard to achieve that goal. The club has succeeded by putting city on their heart and never straying. And that connection to Detroit has made DCFC’s players family for the fans that fill the stands of Keyworth. They cheer for their club because they cheer for their city. It’s time to recognize the gold standard. It’s time to vote for Detroit City FC.

- Dan Vaughn

Club of the Year Nominee: Oakland Roots SC

As a staff, we sat down and discussed which clubs deserved the title “Club of the Year.” Working together over the last three weeks we came up with a list of five. This week, I’ll introduce each club and make the argument for your vote. Saturday morning, voting begins and will continue till the end of the year. January 1, we’ll announce our Protagonist Soccer 2019 Club of the Year. I hope you enjoy these articles and then vote for your club of choice. - Dan

---

There’s a famous Supreme Court decision everyone loves to quote. You may have heard of it, but it happened in 1964, Jacobellis v. Ohio. In that case, Nico Jacobellis ran a movie theater and decided to show a movie the state of Ohio had deemed obscene. When they arrested him and charged him, he challenged the law, lost twice on appeal, and eventually took it all the way to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court reversed the decision, on the grounds that the Constitution didn’t allow regulation of pornography (the film wasn’t porn in our modern sense, just a very artsy French film with sex in it), unless it was “hardcore pornography.” Justice Potter Stewart, who ruled to overrule the lower court’s decision, issued a very quotable dissent when the decision was made. “"I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description; and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it, and the motion picture involved in this case is not that."

“Knowing something when you see it” acknowledges that there are times in life when expressing something may be difficult, even though you know that it is correct. It is not a cop out, but rather a recognition that your gut feeling is correct, with or without the logic to back it up. And maybe it’s difficult to nominate a club that has struggled to produce points on the field and has existed for less than two years, but I know a nominee for club of the year when I see it. That club is Oakland Roots SC.

So let’s consider the case for Oakland Roots for club of the year. Without a doubt, the weakest point on that list is their performance on the field. With a league track record that is only 6 matches long, that isn’t much to go on. And what we do have is weak, points-wise. Roots ended the 2019 NISA campaign with only 3 points, all from draws. Without a win, it should come as no surprise that the club struggled in the goal differential category, ending the season at -3, second worst in the entire competition. But that’s where the negatives end and the narrative turns.

Oakland Roots managed to secure several big friendlies against south of the border competition, including Liga MX first division side, FC Juarez. Against Los Bravos, Roots struggled, yielding the first three goals in 12 minutes. However, for the next 80 minutes, the Oakland side held its own against the better club, finishing the match with a score of 4-2. Their second friendly continued that run, with a great victory over Ascenso MX (Mexican second division) leader CA Zacatepec. Zacatepec won the 2019 Apertura (first half of the league’s year) by a point and probably expected to easily beat Roots. The friendly ended with a scoreline of 2-0, with goals from Jack McInerney and Octavio Guzman. Competing and beating Mexican clubs won’t hurt your standing in the hearts of Californian soccer fans, where Liga MX is the most followed league, especially among Mexican Americans. The club was competing with clubs their local fans watched on tv. The comparisons were authentic and close to their heart.

And that Mexican American demographic is a big one in the city of Oakland. The population is 25% Latino and over 40% of the city speaks a language other than English, but that population is also White, African American, Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Indian, and Cambodian. It’s a diverse population where soccer can serve as a uniting bond. That diversity was a central focus from the beginning with the club. Diversity is authentic to Oakland and that diversity would play a central role in every decision moving forward.

The club was founded by Benno Nagel and Edreece Arghandiwal; Nagel brought years of soccer experience, while Arghandiwal had worked in marketing, brand management, and tech. After deciding they wanted to form a soccer club, they chose NPSL’s Founders Cup as the destination. With FC’s demise, NISA was where Oakland would extend their roots. During the club’s founding, Nagel and Arghandiwal gathered a board of community advisors from diverse backgrounds within the city. Those advisors offered perspective and advice on the decisions that would shape the soccer club as it formed.

The primary focus was that the club would represent Oakland. They used a phrase to guide them “Oakland first, always” and that phrase would lead them to the creation of the club’s iconic logo and overall branding approach. Partnering with Matt Wolf, who has created multiple iconic brands in American soccer (including fellow Californian club, LAFC), they included the Jack London Oak (a symbol of the city, a 100-year old tree that stands in the center of the city) in the design. The club worked with local clothing brand Oaklandish to design a line of clothing that extended the look of the club into everyday apparel. And the branding was such a hit, it began to show up in hip-hop videos, particularly in California-native G-Eazy’s videos. Soon after NBA stars began wearing their apparel. Authenticity is hot.

That approach to authenticity extended to how the club built their roster, going after Oakland native Devante Dubose. When the announcement was made, it was done with an eye-catching video that was widely shared on social media. It featured shot after shot of Oakland, with Dubose wearing Roots gear, eventually ending with a final shot of the player standing in a parking lot with a car drafting in a circle around him. I’m not from Oakland, but it felt authentic. Roots followed that signing more Oakland-raised talent in Julio Cervantes and Yohannes Harish. From there they added more talent like Benji Joya, Victor Bernardez, and Jack McInerney. It was a club built to represent the people who would support it, the authenticity would flow from the stands to the pitch.

And the people did show up. More than any other club in the NISA showcase in the fall of 2019, Oakland showed up for the club’s home matches. Roots averaged over 5,000 fans a match, putting their attendance over the vast majority of USL Championship clubs. The club worked to build on the fan experience, including a season-ending hip-hop show at the final match.

We often talk about how bad branding is so prevalent in American soccer. We scoff at outsiders buying rights to cities and then fumbling basic decisions on how to brand, staff, and run their club. So maybe in 2019 we should trumpet one that got it right, because Oakland Roots nailed it. By focusing on the city they loved, the founders created a club that fans could love. Oakland Roots represents the authenticity, diversity, and the unique makeup of Oakland, California. You should vote for Roots, because just like Justice Potter said, you’ll know it when you see it, and you can see it in Oakland. Oakland First, Always.

- Dan Vaughn